Set in early 20th-century New York City, the story follows Peter Lake, played by Colin Farrell, a skilled thief who finds himself on the run from the menacing crime lord, Pearly Soames, portrayed by Russell Crowe. The film opens with a sense of enchantment, as Peter discovers a mystical white horse, which becomes a symbol of freedom and hope throughout the narrative. This horse is not just a means of escape; it represents the extraordinary possibilities that exist within the ordinary world.

Peter’s life takes a transformative turn when he encounters Beverly Penn, played by Jessica Brown Findlay, a terminally ill young woman living in a wealthy family. Their love story unfolds against the backdrop of the city’s gritty streets and opulent mansions, creating a stark contrast that enhances the film’s emotional depth. The chemistry between Farrell and Findlay is palpable, and their romance is portrayed with sincerity and tenderness. The film beautifully captures the innocence and intensity of their love, emphasizing the notion that true love can transcend time and circumstance.